Autumn is mating season for white-tail deer. The bucks sport fully formed antlers and bulked up necks and shoulders, and they’re busy sparring, posturing, and otherwise asserting their suitability as mates. Antler rubs are an important part of the bucks’ demonstrations. To make a rub a buck approaches a sapling or small tree and works its antlers up and down against the trunk. The rough surfaces at the antler bases act like rasps to remove the bark, and the tips of the tines leave rough gouges. In the center of the rub the exposed wood is bright and relatively smooth, and dislodged bark fibers may hang from the roughened margins.
Buck rubs are only made on living trees, and vertical trunks that have an unobstructed approach are preferred. Buck rubs are generally located between 1 and 3 1/2 feet off the ground and can be found on both hardwoods and conifers up to 10 inches in diameter. The light color of the exposed wood is eye-catching, but the most important part of the message is invisible. The buck deposits chemicals from scent glands in its skin by rubbing its forehead against the surface of the rub. In the process of making a rub a buck stops periodically to sniff the surface. Later, visiting does sniff the rub and take in olfactory messages that reveal the health and status of the rub maker.
Contrary to common belief, buck rubs are not connected with the removal of the velvet, the highly vascularized tissue which nourished the antlers as they grew. By late summer the rack is fully formed, and the velvet is beginning to wither and slough off. This process is assisted when the animals thrash their antlers against shrubs and small trees. By the time the rut begins in earnest the velvet is long gone.
An individual tree may be hit more than once, and a popular one may take on a whimsical appearance. Damage like that shown in the photo above may be enough to kill a young tree.
Rubs from previous years are often found among fresh rubs. Old rubs like the one in the photo below are dulled by weathering and are usually rimmed by callus formed in the growing season following the assault as the tree attempted to heal the wound.
Other animals also remove bark from woody plants, but there are usually clues that help to identify the culprit. Squirrels strip bark from stems and branches to use for nest lining, and stripped stems can look similar to buck rubs. Dead trees or branches are often the source for squirrel nest lining, and in that case we know it can’t be a buck rub. But sometimes the bark fibers are harvested from a living tree or shrub, such as the honeysuckle in the photo below. The lack of abrasion on the debarked area and the undamaged hanging strips signal squirrel rather than deer. Squirrels can gather fibrous bark from stems at any height, and the debarked areas in the photo are closer to the ground than an antler rub would be. If nearby stems or branches obstruct the stripped stem it’s also unlikely to be the work of a deer. And finally, as in the photo, stems harvested by squirrels may not be vertical while buck rubs usually are.
Debarking can also be a result of chewing. In the photo below you see a stem fed on by a cottontail rabbit. The irregular removal of bark and outer wood differs from the vertical bands left by the up and down rubbing of an antler. Rabbit feeding is also usually closer to the ground than would be expected in an antler rub, but keep in mind that deep snow can result in elevated rabbit chews. Porcupines and beavers also chew on shrubs and trees at varied heights. But like the rabbit chew, the tooth marks left by these animals are different enough from the abraded surface left by antler action to separate their chews from buck rubs.
Antler rubs are part of a suite of behaviors that allow male white-tail deer to establish dominance and demonstrate their prowess, but that’s not all there is to it. These behaviors also trigger changes in the females that prime them for mating. Sniffing a rub sends chemical signals to a doe that precipitate a flood of hormones and prepare her for reproduction. Buck rubs are part of an intricate interplay of behaviors that results, if things go well, in the appearance of offspring about 6 1/2 months later.